Kirkwall

Almost all tours in Kirkwall are private or small-group day trips, with 90% priced over £100 and none under £100. The catalogue is dominated by full-day and half-day excursions, with 45% of all products between £100 and £200, and another 30% between £200 and £400. There are no budget options: the lowest 'from' price for any tour is £160.

The best-reviewed tours consistently mention knowledgeable, flexible guides and a tailored experience. 11 of the 20 tours carry the seller's top quality mark, and only 3 are rated below 4 stars. Most tours offer free cancellation, but this is standard rather than a selling point.

Kirkwall lists 20 experiences, almost all private or small-group, with no low-cost or short sightseeing options. The median 'from' price is £219, but this is pulled up by several private tours priced per vehicle, so the per-person median in most categories is lower. 45% of tours are between £100 and £200, 30% between £200 and £400, and 25% over £400. No tour costs less than £160, and none exceed £1000.

Quality marks are common: 11 tours carry the seller's top badge, 4 have the 'Excellent Quality' mark, and just 1 is in the 'Curated Catalog'. Poor ratings are rare, with only 3 tours (15%) below 4 stars. However, every poorly rated tour falls into the same group: nature and wildlife, shore excursions, and bus or car tours, often with operational complaints.

Category labels mix private vehicles and small groups, so price ranges can overlap. For example, 'Bus Tours' includes both private black-cab tours and larger group buses, which explains the wide spread in prices. Only the listed tours specify if the price is per person or per vehicle.

If you want a private experience for a group of up to four, tours priced per vehicle like 'Taxi / Tours of Orkney (self guided)' and 'Orkney Highlights Private Tour' offer the best value, especially when split among several people. These start from £310 per vehicle, making them cheaper per head than most per-person tours if you fill all seats. For solo travellers or couples, per-person tours start at £160, with most full-day options between £160 and £401.

Walking tours are rare but highly rated, with 'Kirkwall Private Walking Tour' at £186 per person and all reviews at 5 stars. Full-day private tours such as 'From Kirkwall - Orkney Mainland Private Tour' (£401 per person) are among the best-reviewed, with guides praised for tailoring the day to guests' interests and needs. Small-group tours like 'Semi Private Tour - Orkney and Kirkwall' (£196 per person) are popular, but reviews show that group delays and inconsistent guiding can disappoint. Complaints about guides acting more as drivers than storytellers are common in these group tours.

The lowest ratings in the catalogue come from nature and wildlife or shore excursions, particularly 'Scapa Tours', where guests report no-shows, poor communication, and difficulties obtaining refunds when ships miss port. These issues are not seen in the top-rated private or walking tours. For per-person products, £160–£200 is a fair price for a half- or full-day tour with a well-reviewed guide. Prices above £400 per person are only justified for highly personalised, full-day private tours with consistent top ratings.

Operational reliability matters: tours with instant confirmation and high review counts are less likely to disappoint. If you want to avoid group delays or guide quality issues, choose a private tour with strong recent reviews and the seller's quality badge. For those relying on cruise schedules, avoid products with repeated complaints about cancellations or no-shows.

Most tours confirm instantly, with 13 out of 20 offering immediate booking and only 3 requiring manual confirmation. Sell-out warnings appear on some of the more popular private and small-group options, especially during cruise season. To guarantee your preferred date and guide, book as early as possible, particularly for private tours or if visiting with a group.

Last-minute availability is limited, and reviews show that operational issues are more likely with less established providers. Booking ahead reduces the risk of disappointment.

Search flights and places to stay. Prices come from Expedia and update live.